China Rights Record Independent evidence desk
← Back to all records
Under ongoing verification Hong Kong and Macau
Published: 2026-11-08 · Event date:2026-11-06

Macau sentences former lawmaker Au Kam San to 12.5 years in the territory's first national security trial, held behind closed doors; Human Rights Watch says the proceedings were marred by due process violations

🔊 A Chinese audio reading of this record is available on the Chinese page. 简体中文

Macau's Court of First Instance sentenced 69-year-old former lawmaker Au Kam San to 12 years and 6 months in prison on November 6, 2026, for subversion of state power, establishing links with foreign groups or individuals to commit activities endangering national security, and violating secrecy. It is the territory's first national security trial, and the first time Macau's national security law — in force since 2009 — has been applied to a political figure. Au was arrested in July 2025 on suspicion of colluding with foreign forces to endanger national security and was tried behind closed doors on September 16 and 18, 2026; the court said that although he was a first-time offender who had admitted a significant portion of the criminal acts, the degree of intent was extremely high and both the unlawfulness of the conduct and its potential consequences were exceptionally grave. The applicable sentencing range was 11 years and 3 months to 19 years and 6 months, and the court imposed a single consolidated sentence of 12 years and 6 months. Reuters, citing local broadcaster TDM, reports that the court acquitted Au on two additional counts of subversion for insufficient evidence; China Daily Asia puts the convictions at five of seven charges, consistent with Reuters (two of seven acquitted); a BBC report carried elsewhere puts it at four of seven — the counts differ, and this site records both. Au is one of Macau's most prominent democracy campaigners, having served nearly two decades in the legislature and long helped organise the annual Tiananmen vigils. Human Rights Watch said the proceedings were 'marred by violations of due process' and the sentence 'sends a chilling message to all peaceful critics in the territory'; his wife called the case 'groundless persecution'. On November 6, the UN Human Rights Office also raised concerns about the Au Kam San case, noting that his conviction followed closed-door proceedings in which he was unable to be represented by a lawyer of his choice — 'a clear violation of the right to a fair hearing'; High Commissioner Volker Türk reiterated his call for convictions and sentences imposed on national security grounds to be carefully reviewed against international human rights obligations. What this record verifies is the publicly reported trial outcome; the closed-door proceedings mean the court disclosed almost no evidence, and the alleged conduct rests on the prosecution's account, hence under ongoing verification. [1][2][3][4][5]

Why it matters

This sentence is worth recording for three reasons. First, it is the first time Macau's national security law has been used: in force since 2009 and broadened by a 2023 revision, it had never before been applied to a political figure in seventeen years; a 12.5-year sentence at first use puts Macau on the same path as Hong Kong in jailing dissenters under national security law, in a city long seen as quieter and more restrained than its neighbour. Second, the procedure itself is the story: a trial held entirely behind closed doors, with the court disclosing almost no evidence or reasoning, and a court-appointed defence lawyer — Human Rights Watch's point is precisely the due process deficit, since a closed trial leaves no way to test whether the 'subversion' and 'collusion' evidence holds up. Third, the timing matters: the sentence came a day after Hong Kong's Joshua Wong received an additional ten years, so the two territories' landmark dissidents were heavily sentenced under national security law within the same week; at 69, a 12.5-year term means Au will spend his 80th birthday in prison. [1][2][3]

Full report

Reuters reported on November 6 (citing Macau broadcaster TDM) that Macau's Court of First Instance sentenced 69-year-old former lawmaker Au Kam San to 12 years and 6 months in prison for subversion of state power, establishing links with foreign groups or individuals to commit activities endangering national security, and violating secrecy. The court said that although the defendant was a first-time offender who had admitted a significant portion of the criminal acts, 'the degree of intent was extremely high, and both the unlawfulness of the conduct and the potential consequences are exceptionally grave.' The applicable range was 11 years and 3 months to 19 years and 6 months, and the court imposed a single consolidated sentence of 12 years and 6 months. The court acquitted Au on two additional counts of subversion due to insufficient evidence. Au was arrested in July 2025 on suspicion of colluding with foreign forces to endanger national security and was tried behind closed doors on September 16 and 18, 2026. [1]

China Daily Asia, citing the case, reported that the court heard Au had colluded with multiple foreign anti-China organisations since 2022, providing them with sensitive and inflammatory information for publication overseas and online to incite hatred against the Macao SAR government and the central government and to sabotage the 2024 chief executive election. That report puts the convictions at five of seven charges, which is consistent with Reuters' account (two of the seven counts acquitted), while a BBC report carried elsewhere puts the convictions at four of seven; this site records both accounts, and the exact conviction count should be checked against the court's formal judgment when published. [3]

Au's background: one of Macau's most prominent democracy campaigners, he served nearly two decades in the legislature, championed democratic reform and civil society causes, and was a key organiser of the annual Tiananmen Square vigils. Macau returned from Portuguese to Chinese rule in 1999; its national security law took effect in 2009, was broadened in 2023 to cover non-violent acts of secession, and a further amendment this year allows trials behind closed doors, which prosecutors said was necessary to avoid prejudice to national security interests. Pro-democracy voices in both Chinese-ruled territories have faced an intense crackdown since Hong Kong's 2019 protest movement. [1][2]

International reaction: Human Rights Watch said the proceedings were 'marred by violations of due process' and the sentence handed down by the Macao government 'sends a chilling message to all peaceful critics in the territory'; HRW deputy Asia director Maya Wang made the same point. Au's wife Virginia Cheang was reported as calling the case 'groundless persecution'. Reuters reported that Au's court-appointed lawyer did not immediately respond to a request for comment. This site has seen no separate public statement on the sentence from the Chinese or Macao governments in the reporting reviewed. [1][2][4]

Verification note and timing: the core facts — the November 6 sentence of 12 years and 6 months, the categories of charges, the July 2025 arrest, and the closed-door trial on September 16 and 18 — rest mainly on Reuters' report citing TDM, corroborated by same-day BBC and Al Jazeera reporting; China Daily Asia's account of the alleged conduct is consistent with Reuters on the conviction count (five of seven), while a BBC report carried elsewhere puts it at four of seven, and the difference is noted as such. The proceedings were held behind closed doors and the court disclosed almost no evidence, so the alleged conduct rests on the prosecution's account and this site has not independently verified it, hence under ongoing verification. [1][2][3][4]

[Updated November 11, 2026] According to the International Service for Human Rights (ISHR) on November 10, the UN Human Rights Office said on November 6 that the harsh penalties imposed under national security legislation in Hong Kong and Macao were 'deeply concerning', and that the convictions and sentences are 'flagrantly incompatible with international human rights law'. On the Au Kam San case, the Office noted that he was sentenced to 12 years and six months in prison in the first known case under Macao's national security law, and that his conviction followed closed-door proceedings in which he was unable to be represented by a lawyer of his choice — 'a clear violation of the right to a fair hearing'. UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Volker Türk reiterated his call for convictions and sentences imposed on national security grounds in Hong Kong, Macao and elsewhere in China to be carefully reviewed against international human rights obligations. The record remains under ongoing verification: the count of convictions (five according to Reuters and China Daily, four according to a BBC republication) still awaits confirmation once the formal judgment is published. [5]

Primary sources

Links above point to the original publishers of the cited reports or articles. Their conclusions are attributed in the text and do not imply that this site has independently verified every factual claim.