西安锡安之光教会高全福牧师 11 月 12 日受审:检方建议判处 12 至 13 年,庭审约 10 小时未当庭宣判,数百警察阻拦旁听者与律师Pastor Gao Quanfu of Xi'an's Light of Zion Church stands trial on November 12: prosecutors seek 12 to 13 years, hearing lasts about 10 hours with no verdict, hundreds of police block observers and lawyers
据对华援助组织(ChinaAid)2026 年 11 月 11 日报道与维权网 11 月 12 日消息,西安锡安之光教会牧师高全福 11 月 12 日在西安市碑林区法院受审,检方建议判处 12 至 13 年,庭审持续约 10 小时,未当庭宣判。高全福 1957 年出生,2025 年 5 月 16 日在家中被西安市碑林区警方带走,最初罪名是涉嫌“利用迷信破坏法律实施罪”,同年 9 月罪名改为“诈骗罪”;2026 年 1 月 9 日,案件移送碑林区法院审查起诉,后拆分为三案分别处理。据维权网引述现场消息,法院周围部署数百名警察及便衣人员,阻止前来旁听的基督徒和律师进入法庭,律师王宇、卢思位、彭永和据称被警方带至公安机关。高全福之妻庞羽(1958 年出生、年近七旬)于 11 月 17 日开庭,截至发稿未见庭审结果报道;另一名教会领袖唐秉义原定 11 月 23 日开庭、现已延期,据聚焦中国 11 月 14 日报道改定 11 月 30 日审理。高全福、庞羽之子高朴携全体亲友 11 月 11 日晚发表公开信,致最高人民检察院检察长应勇与最高人民法院院长张军,指控碑林区检察院与法院在审查起诉与审理中违反法定程序:人为将共同犯罪一案拆成三案、分别制作不同案卷;检察院未依法询问“被害人”、对公安意见照单全收;法院自 2025 年 12 月 31 日起诉至法院后拖延不开庭、也不告知律师审限延长情况;辩护律师发现庞羽案卷中缺少起诉书列名的被害人赵倩的笔录(高全福案卷中有),承办法官雒一先 11 月 6 日当场核对确认、承诺 11 月 9 日前答复,至 11 月 11 日下午仍无答复、法院电话也无法接通;被害人赵玉英的家属委托的代理律师 11 月 9 日至 11 日要求提交手续、阅卷与申请延期开庭,法院一再拖延。公开信恳请最高法与最高检紧急介入调查。上述内容系家属单方陈述,本站未独立核实;11 月 12 日庭审仍按期进行。定性维持持续核实。[1][2][3][4]According to ChinaAid on November 11, 2026 and Weiquanwang on November 12, Pastor Gao Quanfu of Xi'an's Light of Zion Church stood trial on November 12 at the Beilin District People's Court, with prosecutors recommending 12 to 13 years in prison; the hearing lasted about 10 hours and no verdict was announced. Gao, born in 1957, was detained at his home on May 16, 2025 by police in Xi'an's Beilin District, initially on suspicion of 'using superstition to undermine the implementation of the law'; the charge was changed to fraud in September 2025, and on January 9, 2026 the case was transferred to the Beilin District Court and later split into three separately tried cases. Weiquanwang, citing on-site reports, said hundreds of police and plainclothes officers were deployed around the court, blocking Christians and lawyers who came to observe from entering, and that lawyers Wang Yu, Lu Siwei and Peng Yonghe were reportedly taken to public security organs. Gao's wife Pang Yu (born 1958, nearly 70) stood trial on November 17, with no outcome reported at the time of writing; fellow church leader Tang Bingyi, originally scheduled for November 23, has had his hearing postponed and, according to Focus China on November 14, is now set for November 30. This record verifies the reporting of the two organisations; the recommended sentence and the account of the hearing rest on the defence team On the evening of November 11, Gao Pu, the son of Gao Quanfu and Pang Yu, together with the families, published an open letter to Prosecutor-General Ying Yong of the Supreme People's Procuratorate and President Zhang Jun of the Supreme People's Court, accusing the Beilin District Procuratorate and court of violating statutory procedure in prosecuting and trying the case: artificially splitting a joint offence into three cases with separately prepared files; the procuratorate failing to question the 'victims' as required and accepting the police's views wholesale; the court delaying the trial since the case was filed on December 31, 2025 without informing the lawyers of any extension of the trial time limit; and the defence discovering that the file in Pang Yu's case lacked the statement of a listed victim, Zhao Qian, which was present in Gao's file — a discrepancy the presiding judge, Luo Yixian, verified on the spot on November 6 and promised to answer by November 9, but by the afternoon of November 11 there had been no reply and the court's phones were unreachable; lawyers retained by the family of listed victim Zhao Yuying sought on November 9–11 to file their papers, review the files and apply for a postponement, and were repeatedly stalled. The letter asks the Supreme People's Court and the Supreme People's Procuratorate to intervene urgently. The above comes from the families' account and has not been independently verified by this site; the November 12 hearing went ahead as scheduled. The record remains under ongoing verification. [1][2][3][4]
为什么重要WHY IT MATTERS
这起庭审值得记录,有三个原因。其一,量刑建议极重:检方对一名 69 岁的牧师建议判处 12 至 13 年,指控的核心是教会多年的十一奉献、捐款与购书费用被认定为“诈骗所得”——辩护方与宗教自由倡导者认为,这实质上是把家庭教会正常的奉献行为刑事化。其二,庭审程序本身受到质疑:辩护律师要求推延期以便收集证据,维权网称庭审当天数百名警察封锁法院、阻止旁听,三名律师据称被带走;此前 9 月 15 日,代理律师团前往碑林区法院交涉时也曾遭到法警阻挠。其三,这是 2025 年以来针对独立教会的一系列“诈骗罪”起诉中最受关注的一起:同一罪名已用于北京锡安教会、北京嘉泉教会、合肥甘泉教会等多起案件,锡安之光教会本身已有近 40 年历史。本记录与本站 10 月 9 日收录的兰托斯人权奖(锡安教会创办人金明日获奖、八名领袖仍在押)、10 月 15 日收录的锡安教会牧师王琳之妻专访同属独立教会受压的不同侧面;被带走的律师卢思位本人亦为本站 10 月 28 日收录的监控对象。[1][2][3]This trial is worth recording for three reasons. First, the recommended sentence is extremely heavy: prosecutors seek 12 to 13 years for a 69-year-old pastor, with the charge resting on years of tithes, donations and book purchases being treated as proceeds of fraud — the defence and religious freedom advocates argue this effectively criminalises ordinary giving in a house church. Second, the proceedings themselves are in question: defence lawyers asked for a postponement to gather evidence, and Weiquanwang reports that hundreds of police sealed off the court on the day and blocked observers, with three lawyers reportedly taken away; at a September 15 visit to the same court, the defence team had already been obstructed by court police. Third, this is among the most closely watched of a series of fraud prosecutions of independent churches since 2025: the same charge has been used against Beijing Zion Church, Beijing Jiaquan Church, Hefei Ganquan Church and others, and Light of Zion Church itself has operated for nearly 40 years. This record sits alongside this site's October 9 record of the Lantos Human Rights Prize (Zion Church founder Jin Mingri honoured, eight leaders still detained) and its October 15 record of the Amnesty interview with the wife of Zion Church pastor Wang Lin, as different facets of the pressure on independent churches; Lu Siwei, one of the lawyers reportedly taken away, is himself the subject of this site's October 28 record on monitoring after release. [1][2][3]
详细记录Full report
据对华援助组织 11 月 11 日报道与维权网 11 月 9 日、11 月 12 日通报:高全福 1957 年出生,陕西省西安市人,早年从西安话剧院公职出来投身福音传播,是西安市原“锡安山教会”(2023 年 11 月 29 日被西安市民政局明文通告取缔)与现“锡安之光教会”的监督和牧师;他力主拍摄了《从西安到锡安》《西北灵工团历史》两部福音纪录片,2021 年与成都秋雨圣约教会王怡牧师等多名牧者共同签署《牧者联署:为基督信仰的声明》。2025 年 5 月 16 日,他被西安市碑林区兴庆路派出所警方从家中带走,次日教会另 10 名牧者同工被陆续传唤刑拘,最初罪名均为涉嫌“利用迷信破坏法律实施罪”;7 月 24 日,其中 8 名牧者同工获取保释放,只有高全福与唐秉义仍被续押;同年 9 月,碑林区检察院将罪名更改为“诈骗罪”,同日正被监视居住的高全福之妻庞羽也被以“诈骗罪”再次逮捕;2026 年 1 月 9 日,三人案移送碑林区法院审查起诉,后拆分为三案分别处理,三人现羁押于西安市碑林区看守所。[1][2][3]
关于 11 月 12 日的庭审:对华援助组织引述辩护团队的消息称,碑林区法院当天开庭审理高全福案,检方建议判处 12 至 13 年;辩护律师已要求推迟庭审,以便有更多时间收集证据。维权网 11 月 12 日引述现场消息称,庭审持续约 10 小时,未当庭宣判;法院周围部署数百名警察及便衣人员,阻止前来旁听的基督徒和律师进入法庭,王宇、卢思位、彭永和三名律师据称被警方带至公安机关。截至发稿,未见法院就庭审经过、量刑建议或律师被带走一事作出公开说明。[1][2]
关于另外两名被告:庞羽 1958 年出生,长期在教会承担接待、探访与行政事工,从未领取教会工资,却仍被列入“诈骗案”;维权网称她患有心脏病、低血压和严重的焦虑症,羁押后心脏病缺乏有效药物、夜间值班时常剧烈疼痛,辩护团队正为她申请取保就医,她的案件定于 11 月 17 日开庭。唐秉义 1986 年出生,自 2010 年起在教会承担讲道、牧养与探访事工,2025 年 5 月 17 日被带走后一直羁押,原定 11 月 23 日开庭、现已延期,新的开庭日期未公布。[1][2][3]
核实说明与去重:本记录的核心事实——高全福的身份与被带走经过、罪名由“利用迷信破坏法律实施罪”改为“诈骗罪”、案件移送与分案、11 月 12 日开庭约 10 小时未当庭宣判、检方建议判 12 至 13 年、庞羽 11 月 17 日开庭、唐秉义延期——均来自对华援助组织 11 月 11 日报道与维权网 11 月 9 日、11 月 12 日通报,本站逐项核对无误;其中量刑建议系辩护团队的说法、庭审现场情况系维权网引述的现场消息(包括三名律师被带走的说法),本站未独立核实。去重说明:本站此前未收录锡安之光教会高全福案;10 月 25 日轮次筛除的是 9 月 15 日庭前会议冲突的旧闻(ChinaAid 10 月 20 日报道、超窗口),与本次 11 月 12 日正式开庭并非同一事件。截至发稿,未见中方就本案庭审作出公开回应。[1][2][3]
据维权网 11 月 11 日刊登的公开信,高全福、庞羽之子高朴携全体亲友当晚致信最高人民检察院检察长应勇与最高人民法院院长张军,指控碑林区检察院与法院在审查起诉与审理高全福、庞羽、唐秉义一案中违反法定程序。信中称,办案单位通过威胁、诱骗等方式强逼信徒承认给教会的奉献款为被诈骗的财产,并人为将一个共同犯罪的案件分成三个案件、分别制造不同的案卷材料;审查起诉阶段,检察院未依法对“被害人”进行询问、对公安的意见照单全收,以三个案件将本案起诉至法院。信中还称,案件自 2025 年 12 月 31 日起诉至法院以来,法院拖延不开庭、也不告知律师审限延长情况;律师阅卷后发现检察院未按规定制作被害人名单及相应联系方式,要求法院督催检察院提供,承办法官仅口头答复称检察院认定的被害人就是审计报告列名的 235 名被害人。11 月 6 日与承办法官见面时,辩护律师提出庞羽案卷中没有起诉书列名的被害人赵倩的笔录、而高全福案卷中有,雒一先法官现场核对法院存留的庞羽案卷宗后确认确实没有赵倩的笔录,并承诺在 11 月 9 日前给出处理答复;但时至 11 月 11 日下午,碑林区法院不仅没有答复律师,法院电话甚至被设置为无法接通。信中还称,被认定为被害人的赵玉英及其亲属得知被害人有权委托律师出庭后紧急委托了代理律师,代理律师 11 月 9 日联系法院称将于 11 月 11 日到法院阅卷、参加诉讼,11 月 11 日上午电话联系法院时助理称要请示法官是否接收手续,下午代理人到法院要求提交手续、阅卷并申请延期开庭,拨打法院电话 10 余次无人接听、办公室也无人接待;11 月 10 日,部分代理人得知碑林区法院已通知律师所在地司法局派员旁听庭审、以监督律师庭审。公开信恳请最高人民法院与最高人民检察院紧急介入、对办案单位的相关违法行为调查并严肃处理。本记录的定性维持持续核实:上述内容系家属公开信的单方陈述,本站未独立核实;11 月 12 日庭审仍按期进行,未当庭宣判(见本记录前文)。[4]
据聚焦中国 11 月 14 日与基督教新闻平台 ingrace.cc 11 月 12 日报道,11 月 12 日庭审当天法院外围的管控细节陆续公开:人权律师卢思位上午 9 时左右在距离碑林区法院约 30 米处被警察拦下查验身份证件,询问对方身份与执法依据后发生争执,随后被带离;卢思位称带离过程中有警员用膝盖撞击其腰臀部,他要求现场律师王宇协助呼叫急救,未获及时处理;他被送往碑林区太白路派出所接受询问,下午 4 时以后派出所才向他出具传唤证,晚上接近 9 时获释,整个过程接近 12 小时,其间一度无法正常联系外界。另据现场消息,包龙军、王宇、江天勇、彭永和等律师当天也在法院附近被拦截,王宇与卢思位一度与外界失联;卢思位 13 时 20 分向友人发出简短求救信息,称自己正被控制于太白路派出所。聚焦中国还披露,一名 70 多岁的女性教会成员 11 月 11 日晚 8 时左右被公安、国保、街道、宗教事务、统战与社区工作人员共约 8 人上门要求次日不要前往法院,次日清晨 5 时 30 分她准备出门时已有人守候在住所附近;一名辩护律师肖一丹据称未能正常参加当天庭审。上述内容系当事人与律师的单方陈述,本站未独立核实;碑林区法院与太白路派出所截至发稿未就庭审外围管控与律师被控制一事发表公开声明。定性维持持续核实。[5][6]
According to ChinaAid's November 11 report and Weiquanwang's November 9 and November 12 bulletins: Gao Quanfu, born in 1957 in Xi'an, Shaanxi, left a public post at the Xi'an Drama Theatre to devote himself to evangelism, and became supervisor and pastor of the former Mount Zion Church (banned by the Xi'an Civil Affairs Bureau on November 29, 2023) and the present Light of Zion Church; he led the production of two evangelical documentaries, 'From Xi'an to Zion' and 'History of the Northwest Spiritual Workers' Group', and in 2021 signed the 'Pastors' Joint Statement: A Declaration for the Christian Faith' with Pastor Wang Yi of Chengdu's Early Rain Covenant Church and other pastors. On May 16, 2025, he was taken from his home by police from the Xingqing Road station in Beilin District; the next day, ten more pastors and co-workers were detained, all initially on suspicion of 'using superstition to undermine the implementation of the law'; on July 24, eight of them were released on bail, while only Gao and Tang Bingyi remained in custody; in September, the Beilin District Procuratorate changed the charge to fraud, and on the same day Gao's wife Pang Yu, who had been under residential surveillance, was formally arrested on fraud charges; on January 9, 2026, the three-person case was transferred to the Beilin District Court for prosecution review and later split into three separately tried cases; the three are held at the Beilin District Detention Centre. [1][2][3]
On the November 12 hearing: ChinaAid, citing the defence team, reported that the Beilin District Court tried Gao's case that day and that prosecutors recommended 12 to 13 years in prison; defence lawyers had asked for the hearing to be postponed to allow more time to gather evidence. Weiquanwang reported on November 12, citing on-site reports, that the hearing lasted about 10 hours and no verdict was announced; hundreds of police and plainclothes officers were deployed around the court, blocking Christians and lawyers who came to observe from entering, and lawyers Wang Yu, Lu Siwei and Peng Yonghe were reportedly taken to public security organs. At the time of writing, the court has not publicly commented on the hearing, the recommended sentence or the lawyers being taken away. [1][2]
On the other two defendants: Pang Yu, born in 1958, long handled reception, visits and administrative work in the church and never drew a church salary, yet was still listed in the fraud case; Weiquanwang says she suffers from heart disease, low blood pressure and severe anxiety, and that in detention she has lacked effective medication for her heart condition and often suffers severe pain at night on duty, and the defence team is seeking her release on bail for medical treatment; her case is scheduled for trial on November 17. Tang Bingyi, born in 1986, has handled preaching, pastoral care and visits in the church since 2010 and was detained on May 17, 2025; his trial, originally scheduled for November 23, has been postponed, with no new date announced. [1][2][3]
Verification note and deduplication: the core facts of this record — Gao's identity and the course of his detention, the change of charge from 'using superstition to undermine the implementation of the law' to fraud, the transfer of the case and its division into three, the November 12 hearing lasting about 10 hours with no verdict, the prosecutors' recommendation of 12 to 13 years, Pang Yu's trial on November 17 and Tang Bingyi's postponement — all come from ChinaAid's November 11 report and Weiquanwang's November 9 and November 12 bulletins, checked item by item by this site; the recommended sentence rests on the defence team's account and the hearing details on Weiquanwang's on-site reports (including the claim that three lawyers were taken away), which this site has not independently verified. On deduplication: this site has not previously recorded the Light of Zion Church Gao Quanfu case; the October 25 round screened out a ChinaAid October 20 report about a conflict at a September 15 pre-trial meeting (outside the window), which is a different event from this November 12 trial. At the time of writing, no public response from the Chinese side to the trial has been seen. [1][2][3]
[Updated November 14, 2026] According to an open letter carried by Weiquanwang on November 11, Gao Pu, the son of Gao Quanfu and Pang Yu, together with the families, wrote that evening to Prosecutor-General Ying Yong of the Supreme People's Procuratorate and President Zhang Jun of the Supreme People's Court, accusing the Beilin District Procuratorate and court of violating statutory procedure in prosecuting and trying the cases of Gao Quanfu, Pang Yu and Tang Bingyi. The letter says the investigators used threats and inducements to force believers to admit that their offerings to the church were defrauded property, and artificially split a joint offence into three cases with separately prepared case files; at the prosecution-review stage, the procuratorate failed to question the 'victims' as required and accepted the police's views wholesale, indicting the case as three separate cases. The letter further says that since the case was filed with the court on December 31, 2025, the court has delayed the trial without informing the lawyers of any extension of the trial time limit; after reviewing the files, the defence found the procuratorate had not prepared a list of victims with contact details as required and asked the court to press the procuratorate to provide it, but the presiding judge only replied orally that the victims recognised by the procuratorate were the 235 named in the audit report. At a meeting with the presiding judge on November 6, the defence pointed out that the file in Pang Yu's case contained no statement by a listed victim, Zhao Qian, while Gao's file did; Judge Luo Yixian checked the court's copy of Pang Yu's file on the spot and confirmed the statement was indeed missing, promising an answer by November 9 — yet by the afternoon of November 11 the Beilin District Court had given no answer and its phones were set to unreachable. The letter also says that Zhao Yuying, a listed victim, and her family urgently retained counsel after learning that victims may instruct lawyers to appear in court; the lawyer contacted the court on November 9 saying he would come on November 11 to review the files and take part, was told on the morning of November 11 that the assistant would have to ask the judge whether the papers would be accepted, and in the afternoon went to the court to file papers, review the files and apply for a postponement, calling more than ten times without answer and finding no one in the office to receive him; on November 10, some of the representatives learned that the court had asked the lawyers' local justice bureaus to send staff to observe the trial and supervise the lawyers. The letter asks the Supreme People's Court and the Supreme People's Procuratorate to intervene urgently and investigate the case-handling units' unlawful conduct. The record remains under ongoing verification: the above comes from the families' open letter and has not been independently verified by this site; the November 12 hearing went ahead as scheduled and ended without a verdict (see above). [4]
[Updated November 17, 2026] According to Focus China on November 14 and the Christian news platform ingrace.cc on November 12, details of the security operation around the court on November 12 have emerged: human rights lawyer Lu Siwei was stopped by police at about 9 a.m. some 30 metres from the Beilin District People's Court and asked to show identification; after he asked the officers to identify themselves and state the legal basis, an argument followed and he was taken away; Lu says an officer struck his lower back and hip with a knee during the removal, and his request for the lawyer Wang Yu, who was present, to call an ambulance was not dealt with promptly; he was taken to the Taibai Road police station for questioning, was only issued a summons after 4 p.m., and was released at close to 9 p.m., a process lasting nearly 12 hours, during which he was at times unable to contact the outside world. According to on-site accounts, the lawyers Bao Longjun, Wang Yu, Jiang Tianyong, Peng Yonghe and Lu Siwei were all intercepted near the court that day, and Wang Yu and Lu Siwei lost contact with the outside world for a time; at 1:20 p.m. Lu sent a brief distress message to a friend saying he was being held at the Taibai Road station. Focus China also reports that a woman church member aged over 70 was visited at about 8 p.m. on November 11 by some eight people from the police, state security, the street office, religious-affairs and united-front departments and the neighbourhood committee, who told her not to go to the court the next day, and that when she prepared to leave at 5:30 a.m. the next morning, people were already waiting near her home; a defence lawyer, Xiao Yidan, was said to have been unable to attend the hearing as normal. The above comes from the parties and lawyers concerned and has not been independently verified by this site; the Beilin District People's Court and the Taibai Road police station had issued no public statement on the security operation or the lawyers' detention at the time of writing. The record remains under ongoing verification. [5][6]
核实来源
- 对华援助组织(ChinaAid),2026-11-11:“Chinese pastor faces up to 13 years in prison ahead of imminent trial”——西安市碑林区法院定于 11 月 12 日开庭审理锡安之光教会高全福牧师案、11 月 17 日审理其妻庞羽案,检方建议对高全福判处 12 至 13 年;辩护律师要求推迟 11 月 12 日的庭审以便收集证据;庞羽年近七旬,羁押期间健康状况恶化,辩护团队正为她申请取保就医;唐秉义原定 11 月 23 日开庭、现已延期,三案同源但分案审理;案件始于 2025 年 5 月 16 日,高全福最初被控“利用迷信破坏法律实施罪”,2025 年 9 月罪名改为诈骗罪,2026 年 1 月移送碑林区法院;锡安之光教会已有近 40 年历史,在政府认可的三自体系之外运作、依靠信徒自愿奉献;检方指控教会领袖以欺骗手段获取奉献,家属否认指控;辩护律师还指控存在程序违规,包括不当地把信徒列为诈骗受害者,据教会方面称当局诱导 200 多名信徒作出指控教会领袖的陈述
- 维权网,2026-11-12:“西安锡安之光教会高全福牧师案今开庭 未当庭宣判”——高全福案 11 月 12 日在西安市碑林区法院开庭,庭审持续约 10 小时,未当庭宣判;据现场消息,法院周围部署数百名警察及便衣人员,阻止前来旁听的基督徒和律师进入法庭,王宇、卢思位、彭永和三名律师据称被警方带至公安机关;另附高全福简历与案件经过(2025 年 5 月 16 日被带走、9 月罪名改为诈骗罪、2026 年 1 月 9 日移送法院审查起诉、后分案处理、现羁押于碑林区看守所)
- 维权网,2026-11-09:“锡安之光教会案通报:高全福牧师案将于 2026 年 11 月 12 日开庭,庞羽师母案将于 11 月 17 日开庭,唐秉义牧师原定 11 月 23 日开庭,现已延期”——高全福、庞羽、唐秉义三人被控“诈骗罪”、分案审理,律师希望推迟高全福庭审以便收集证据,年近 70 岁的庞羽因健康问题正在申请取保就医;另附三人详细简历:高全福 1957 年出生、原锡安山教会(2023 年 11 月 29 日被取缔)监督和牧师,2021 年与王怡等多名牧者签署《牧者联署:为基督信仰的声明》;庞羽 1958 年出生、患心脏病、低血压和严重焦虑症,羁押后缺乏有效药物;唐秉义 1986 年出生,2025 年 5 月 17 日被带走;9 月 15 日代理律师团前往碑林区法院交涉时遭到法警阻挠
- 维权网,2026-11-11:“高全福、庞羽之子高朴携全体亲友致最高人民检察院应勇检察长及最高人民法院张军院长的公开信”——高朴携全体亲友致信最高人民检察院检察长应勇与最高人民法院院长张军,指控碑林区检察院与法院在审查起诉与审理高全福、庞羽、唐秉义一案中违反法定程序:人为将共同犯罪一案拆成三案、分别制作不同案卷;检察院未依法询问“被害人”、对公安意见照单全收;法院自 2025 年 12 月 31 日起诉至法院后拖延不开庭、也不告知律师审限延长情况;辩护律师发现庞羽案卷中缺少起诉书列名的被害人赵倩的笔录(高全福案卷中有),承办法官雒一先 11 月 6 日当场核对确认、承诺 11 月 9 日前答复,至 11 月 11 日下午仍无答复、法院电话也无法接通;被害人赵玉英的家属委托的代理律师 11 月 9 日至 11 日要求提交手续、阅卷与申请延期开庭,法院一再拖延;11 月 10 日部分代理人得知法院已通知律师所在地司法局派员旁听庭审;公开信恳请最高法与最高检紧急介入调查
- 聚焦中国,2026-11-14:“西安高全福案开庭十小时:律师遭警方控制近12小时,法院外围拦截旁听者”——卢思位 11 月 12 日上午 9 时左右在法院约 30 米处被拦,带往太白路派出所,传唤证下午 4 时后才出具,晚上近 9 时获释,控制近 12 小时;卢思位称带离时警员膝盖撞击其腰臀部;70 多岁女信徒 11 月 11 日晚 8 时被 8 人上门要求次日不要去法院,次日清晨 5 时 30 分已有人守候;辩护律师肖一丹据称未能正常参加庭审;唐秉义案定于 11 月 30 日审理;庞羽案定于 11 月 17 日开庭
- ingrace.cc,2026-11-12:“西安家庭教会牧师受审,多名维权律师在法院外失联或被警方控制”——11 月 12 日上午 9 时许,包龙军、王宇、江天勇、彭永和与卢思位在碑林区法院约 30 米处被拦截,王宇和卢思位与外界失联;13 时 20 分卢思位向友人发出求救信息,称正被控制于太白路派出所;11 月 11 日下午王宇和卢思位曾前往碑林区法院询问旁听手续,主办法官电话无人接听;法院曾发函至律师执业所在地司法行政部门,要求派员到场旁听以“监督”律师庭审表现;截至发稿,碑林区法院与太白路派出所未就庭审进展及律师被控制一事发表公开声明
Primary sources
- ChinaAid, November 11, 2026: 'Chinese pastor faces up to 13 years in prison ahead of imminent trial' — the Beilin District People's Court in Xi'an scheduled Pastor Gao Quanfu of Light of Zion Church for trial on November 12 and his wife Pang Yu for November 17, with prosecutors recommending 12 to 13 years for Gao; defence lawyers asked to postpone the November 12 hearing to gather evidence; Pang, nearly 70, suffers from underlying health conditions that have worsened in detention, and her defence team is seeking her release on bail for medical treatment; Pastor Tang Bingyi was originally scheduled for November 23 but his hearing has been postponed without a new date, and the three face charges from the same investigation but are being prosecuted separately; the case began on May 16, 2025, when Gao was detained at home on suspicion of 'using superstition to undermine the implementation of the law', with ten other pastors and co-workers detained the next day; in September 2025 Pang was formally arrested on fraud allegations and the charges against Gao and Tang were changed to fraud; the case was transferred to the Beilin District People's Court in January 2026; Light of Zion Church has operated in Xi'an for nearly 40 years, outside the government-sanctioned Three-Self Patriotic Movement, relying on voluntary offerings; prosecutors allege church leaders obtained offerings through deception, but Gao's family disputes the accusations; defence lawyers have also alleged procedural violations, including improper efforts to classify congregants as fraud victims, and according to the church the authorities induced more than 200 members to provide statements accusing church leaders
- Weiquanwang, November 12, 2026: 'Pastor Gao Quanfu of Xi'an Light of Zion Church stands trial today, no verdict announced' — Gao's case was tried on November 12 at the Beilin District People's Court in Xi'an, lasting about 10 hours with no verdict announced; according to on-site reports, hundreds of police and plainclothes officers were deployed around the court, blocking Christians and lawyers who came to observe from entering, and lawyers Wang Yu, Lu Siwei and Peng Yonghe were reportedly taken to public security organs; the article also carries Gao's biography and case history (detained May 16, 2025; charge changed to fraud in September; case transferred to the court on January 9, 2026 and later split; currently held at the Beilin District Detention Centre)
- Weiquanwang, November 9, 2026: 'Light of Zion Church case bulletin: Pastor Gao Quanfu's case to be tried on November 12, 2026, Pang Yu's case on November 17, Pastor Tang Bingyi's originally scheduled November 23 hearing now postponed' — Gao, Pang and Tang are charged with fraud and tried separately; lawyers hope to postpone Gao's hearing to gather evidence, and Pang, nearly 70, is applying for bail for medical treatment on health grounds; detailed biographies of the three: Gao, born 1957, supervisor and pastor of the former Mount Zion Church (banned November 29, 2023), signed the 2021 Pastors' Joint Statement with Wang Yi and others; Pang, born 1958, suffers from heart disease, low blood pressure and severe anxiety, and has lacked effective medication in detention; Tang, born 1986, detained May 17, 2025; on September 15 the defence team was obstructed by court police when visiting the Beilin District Court
- Weiquanwang, November 11, 2026: 'Open letter from Gao Pu, son of Gao Quanfu and Pang Yu, and all the families to Prosecutor-General Ying Yong of the Supreme People's Procuratorate and President Zhang Jun of the Supreme People's Court' — Gao Pu and the families accuse the Beilin District Procuratorate and court of violating statutory procedure in prosecuting and trying the cases of Gao Quanfu, Pang Yu and Tang Bingyi: artificially splitting a joint offence into three cases with separately prepared files; the procuratorate failing to question the 'victims' as required and accepting the police's views wholesale; the court delaying the trial since the case was filed on December 31, 2025 without informing the lawyers of any extension of the trial time limit; the defence discovering that Pang Yu's file lacked the statement of listed victim Zhao Qian (present in Gao's file), which Presiding Judge Luo Yixian verified on the spot on November 6 and promised to answer by November 9, with no reply by the afternoon of November 11 and the court's phones unreachable; lawyers retained by the family of listed victim Zhao Yuying seeking on November 9–11 to file papers, review the files and apply for a postponement, and being repeatedly stalled; on November 10 the representatives learning the court had asked the lawyers' local justice bureaus to send staff to observe the trial; the letter asks the Supreme People's Court and the Supreme People's Procuratorate to intervene urgently
- Focus China, November 14, 2026: “西安高全福案开庭十小时:律师遭警方控制近12小时,法院外围拦截旁听者” (Gao Quanfu's case heard for ten hours in Xi'an: lawyer held by police for nearly 12 hours, observers blocked around the court) — Lu Siwei was stopped at about 9 a.m. on November 12 some 30 metres from the court, taken to the Taibai Road police station, issued a summons only after 4 p.m. and released at close to 9 p.m., a process of nearly 12 hours; Lu says an officer struck his lower back and hip with a knee during the removal; a woman church member aged over 70 was visited at about 8 p.m. on November 11 by eight people telling her not to go to the court, with people waiting near her home at 5:30 a.m. the next day; defence lawyer Xiao Yidan was said to have been unable to attend the hearing as normal; Tang Bingyi's case is set for November 30; Pang Yu's case is set for November 17
- ingrace.cc, November 12, 2026: “西安家庭教会牧师受审,多名维权律师在法院外失联或被警方控制” (Xi'an house-church pastor stands trial; several rights lawyers lose contact or are held by police outside the court) — at about 9 a.m. on November 12, Bao Longjun, Wang Yu, Jiang Tianyong, Peng Yonghe and Lu Siwei were intercepted some 30 metres from the Beilin District People's Court, and Wang Yu and Lu Siwei lost contact with the outside world; at 1:20 p.m. Lu sent a distress message to a friend saying he was being held at the Taibai Road police station; on the afternoon of November 11, Wang Yu and Lu Siwei had gone to the court to ask about observer procedures and the presiding judge's phone went unanswered; the court had written to the judicial administration where the lawyers practise, asking it to send staff to observe the hearing to “supervise” the lawyers' conduct; at the time of writing, the court and the police station had issued no public statement on the hearing or the lawyers' detention
上述链接是所引用报告或文章的原始发布方。其结论已在正文中明确归属,不代表本站独立完成了全部事实认定。Links above point to the original publishers of the cited reports or articles. Their conclusions are attributed in the text and do not imply that this site has independently verified every factual claim.
